IIlikeTrains
Guest
- Joined
- Dec 1969
- Messages
- 0
- Likes
- 0
Alot of people are complaining that the rp in MTA:RP is poor and that the server is full of noobs, I personally think the reason behind it is the easy way of punishment by admins, I will give you an example:
I am just back on the server and have decided to rp as a criminal, As all criminals start off I rob people. Me and my associate IG spotted a man in the street and decided to rob him and soon as we attempted to rp he ran off down an alley, It was a secluded alley so we pulled out our guns and attempted to get him on the ground. The player then proceed to "ass-pull" a gun (With no rp). *Player getting robbed right leg was hit.
[English] Player getting robbed says: fuck.
That was all he did and then he shot at us, So as only player we decided to F2 and get an admin on the situation (Took 15 mins to get one :/ ) The admin watched over the rp as the player refused to rp, Least to say he was jailed........ For 30 mins. Ass pulling weapon, refusing to rp, Refusing to rp, Refusing to listen to admin and not rp'ing injuries was a 30 mins sentence. I think that was abit low, I thought he was going to give him a warn aswell but no. (Im not saying the admins name because this is not an attack on a particular admin it seems to be the norm for all admins now)
I found it abit suspicious that someone would willingly want to get jailed and then I found out why, The player had guns AND $450,000 on him at the time. Least to say thats a good robbery, So we asked to get the items because at the end of the day we robbed him, we should have the money and guns rp'ly but no, One admin just tp'd away when we were asking and another refused to answer me because "He was off duty" (he was sitting in a car doing nothing, Wasn't driving)
So to re-cap the player who refused to rp got away with a very short jailtime but kept his money and guns with no warning. This is the reason for the large amount of non-rp withing the server, Its not because players are bad at rp, its because the consequences of admin jails are better than the consequences of rp'ing the situation, Which is a bad way to be in an rp server.
I would like to re-enforce my statment that this is not an attack on any players or admins. (No admins or players will be named in the post and any logs used have been modified so there are no names)
LActive member
- Joined
- Apr 2013
- Messages
- 176
- Likes
- 0
🎮 856 hrs💰 $1.1M
+1 on this , I completely agree with you ..
I got to admit i have done this myself in the past , and lets be honest here i think everyone has .. I think sometimes not loosing any items is worth a 30-1 hour admin jail , you can just minimize whilst your in jail and do whateva stalk on facebook , tweet celebs i dunno lol . But its bullshit .
If there is a situation where players are trying to RP with someone and the Target who's getting robbed refuses to RP because he has alot of cash on him or guns , I think the guns and money should be automatically given to the Robbers and he should also recieve admin jail . End of the day I have sometimes had to play with someone refusing to RP for upto an hour before .
I actually think we have a good RP bunch of players on and the server is also getting more busy .

Donator
Donator
- Joined
- Aug 2012
- Messages
- 326
- Likes
- 0
Well I see what your saying. The lower amount of jails, the higher the noobs. But you still have to think second hand, "Oh he doesn't know how to RP well. Let me see if I can run a RP school for this poor non-rping man.". I see what your saying. So yea.....
| Name | Career | Alive/Dead | Net worth |
| Dominique Dinapoli | | Dead | $14,543,875 |
| Hannah Calderon | | Alive | $58,592 |
| Dominque Wash Jr. | | Alive | $ 29,158 |
| Dominic Harnando | | Alive | $ 46,127 |

MTA:RP Forum Legend
- Joined
- Jun 2012
- Messages
- 925
- Likes
- 3
Not really.. We can jail a player for 2 hours but what does it matter? He/she probably goes to another server. Ofcourse that "newb" would be gone but thats not the point of punishing.
The real point of it is to make clear to the player that he's doing something wrong. Jailing him for 30 minuts or 1 hour doesn't really change the subject.
Even if you RP'ed it and he refused to give it then you wouldn't get it anyways. Since the player must agree.
Noobs have always been a problem at any MTA server. It's because we don't only got English people here.
We could spend years on them to train them, learn them and do whats good for the server BUT it would take us way to much time.
Since you or anyone else as a player wants to be helped to.
If players are really dedicated to the server we'd like them to help us.
Try to teach those "noobs"
If you want to go private i'd even TP you to a private location.
If it's not working out then we'll kick him out of the server.
Since we don't mind newbs, but we've got a limit (as in. Not understanding/being able to write English has no use in here)

Active characters:
- Riccardo "Fatman" Whirlen (LSPD Commander)
- Sheldon Dashawn (Walking around)
- Sakaku Takashi (The Golden Lotus founder)
Lace up your boots, cause I'm about to shoot
A true motherfucker going out for the loot
LActive member
- Joined
- Apr 2013
- Messages
- 176
- Likes
- 0
🎮 856 hrs💰 $1.1M
Well i don't think new players are the problem because admin jail for them is a punishment for them , im on about players who have alot of items mabe quite abit of time spent on there acc , knowing loosing a gun and some ammo is alot and hard to get so they sooner spent time in jail then get done over thats what i think
IIlikeTrains
Guest
- Joined
- Dec 1969
- Messages
- 0
- Likes
- 0
@Stick I think you mis-understood the theme of my argument let me reiterate it for ya. My argument isn't to jail all "noobs" for the longest amount of time possible regardless of the crime, My argument is that the admin jail should have far more consequence on the player than continuing with the rp. My example that I showed you up top is perfect, The character there clearly knew that he would be better off being jailed than continuing with the rp.
This is the reason for the problem with rp. It's not because of the "noobs" its because its better off to get admin jailed than to rp. Also this then manipulates player in the server because they think "Well if that player is better off why should I rp?" and in turn creating the situation we have today.

MTA:RP Forum Legend
- Joined
- Jun 2012
- Messages
- 925
- Likes
- 3
It's up to him to give his stuff anyways, he's not forced. So i'm pretty sure he wouldn't give it anyways :P

Active characters:
- Riccardo "Fatman" Whirlen (LSPD Commander)
- Sheldon Dashawn (Walking around)
- Sakaku Takashi (The Golden Lotus founder)
Lace up your boots, cause I'm about to shoot
A true motherfucker going out for the loot
IIlikeTrains
Guest
- Joined
- Dec 1969
- Messages
- 0
- Likes
- 0
@Stick Well he's playing on a rp server, and he was getting robbed. So in real life and the title Roleplay suggests, No he wouldn't have a choice. 2 men are holding guns at him so he would have to give the money.
I also played for about 7 hours yesterday and attempted 8 robberies, This may seem like alot but only 2 of the 8 were successful. and I don't mean the other got away 3 logged off and 4 FOUGHT with the admin to get admin jailed.
Just wanna make sure you understand this: The players instead of rp'ing fought with the admin with the argument jail me instead of me rp'ing. That to me is crazy how you can have a rp server with admins trying to persuade players to rp instead of getting jailed.

MTA:RP Forum Legend
- Joined
- Jun 2012
- Messages
- 925
- Likes
- 3
The fact that you've done 2 robbery's in 7 hours seems like you're not a good illegal RP'er at all.
Just sayin'.

Active characters:
- Riccardo "Fatman" Whirlen (LSPD Commander)
- Sheldon Dashawn (Walking around)
- Sakaku Takashi (The Golden Lotus founder)
Lace up your boots, cause I'm about to shoot
A true motherfucker going out for the loot
LActive member
- Joined
- Apr 2013
- Messages
- 176
- Likes
- 0
🎮 856 hrs💰 $1.1M
I personally think if someone is getting robbed and tries to avoid the RP and argues his way to admin jail , the punishment should be whatever money he has on him and also any items that can be traded should be given to the robbers , and also a admin jail . This will probably help the server aswell .
RDonator
Donator
- Joined
- Apr 2013
- Messages
- 160
- Likes
- 1
Roberies are Almost a NO and I thought you HAD to have an admin or staff watch the rp Roberies are a 2 times a week thing in good ilegal rp. and it can be PASSIVE ROBERIES. you dont have to rob an actualy player you can rob a place for GENERIC Items! its not that hard
IIlikeTrains
Guest
- Joined
- Dec 1969
- Messages
- 0
- Likes
- 0
@Stick what am I meant to do as a rp thief? and why would I stop all of a sudden when the police seem to be non existent?

MTA:RP Forum Legend
Donator
- Joined
- Dec 2012
- Messages
- 1,979
- Likes
- 4
Story of MTA lmao
"I'm bored, let's go rob someone 'cause we can"
"Hey, we can also use guns that are rarely used IRL too!"
"Oh, we can also torture the bastard because I see it in movies all the time!"
"Let's make sure he doesn't tell on us either, we should kill him, it's entirely realistic too, wikipedia said so!"
"We also need to ensure we rob someone everytime we're bored, that way everyone gets robbed once or twice a week and we share the love."
Stop being a moron for two seconds and use that pink smushy substance in your skull. I assume it's no longer solid so best of luck.
Last edited Jul 16, 2013
“
I know, up on top you are seeing great sights, but down here at the bottom we, too, should have rights.”
―
Dr. Seuss, Yertle the Turtle and Gertrude McFuzz
Contact me:
here.
IIlikeTrains
Guest
- Joined
- Dec 1969
- Messages
- 0
- Likes
- 0
@Beatty I rp'd as many things actually I was a cop in your PD as Vlad Govorov, I was a lawyer in the FC as Kevin Sweeney, I was a fireman and medic in LSES as Colm McGurran, A property and vehicle dealer Vlad Govorov and now I am a criminal. Its not like I just rp as a criminal all the time so I dont know what your complaining about :L
And anyway this has strayed way to far from the point I was making, My point was that players find it better to be in trouble with the admins then to rp a situation and that should not be the way.
Last edited Jul 16, 2013

Active member
- Joined
- Jan 2013
- Messages
- 178
- Likes
- 1
The solution is very simple. When creating an account then there should be like "dispatches" who will contact the person who requested an account.
That "dispatch" would ask him some questions and make this player more experienced on RP.
Also, players who still are refusing RPing repeatly should be like disabled from the server (not banned) until they've contact with the dispatch to discuss the problem and the "dispatch" can give him some hints and tips.
Who can be "dispatches"? Everyone who can roleplay BUT admins can view logs of every dispatch. If someone's like "Oh Hi, it's me, your friend IG. I'll give you back your access to server lol... these admins are noob lol" then this player would gain a warn and will be removed from the "dispatch" unit.
Well it does sound grazy but it will help.

The real MVP
- Joined
- Nov 2012
- Messages
- 1,188
- Likes
- 12
We have a system for that in place.
Its called Force Application(/forceapp). This makes the player sign on to the UCP and answer a few questions as well as provide examples of his/her rp. Then administrators review and accept or deny the requests. I have handled a few myself
MNew member
- Joined
- Mar 2013
- Messages
- 7
- Likes
- 1
I used to be a very good roleplayer, then I joined MTA:RP.