Brawls with Fists, and Melee Weapons

Started by Vanilla Bean · Sep 13, 2014 at 7:42 PM
075073078071
Joined
May 2014
Messages
211
Likes
0
Sep 13, 2014 at 7:42 PM#1
New Suggestion/Idea



What does it affect?
Tick all that apply
[X] MTA:RP Gameplay
[ ] User Interface
[ ] MTA:RP Forums
[ ] UCP
[ ] Only MTA:RP Staff (Administration Tools)
[ ] Other _______________

Please provide a brief summary of your Suggestion/Idea
- I've always loved brawls, they're so simple, yet fun, and can be tricky. Instead of the old /me attempts to punch Bob, then /do Bob jumps three thousand feet back and avoids the punch like superman.

I am suggesting that we allow for members who have an IC reason to fight to be able to throw punches, use bats, shovels, and knives without having to use /me's. This voids so much QQ, and power gaming, and plus it's extremely fun. At any time, the people fighting can give up, or attempt to run away. Players fighting can either chose to leave the loser knocked out and give them the chance for LSES to come, or beat them until they're PK'd.

Here's the catch, you may only brawl if all fighters from both sides agree to it OOC. This worked at - and is still working till this very day at LS-RP. At the end of the day we are all here to have fun, and not get pissed off when people QQ, and powergame. Let's bring the fun back into roleplay.

Advantages/Benefits
- Makes fighting actually interesting
- Players can chose to brawl using OOC communication
- Eliminates all QQ
- Eliminates all PG

Disadvantages
If any


Does it require scripting?
Tick one
[X] No.
[ ] Yes, I have the script.
[ ] Yes, but it still needs to be scripted.

How would you go about implementing this suggestion?
Make a thread to explain the changes, and alter anything that may need to be altered.

Impact the suggestion would have if implemented
Very postives effects.

Additional information:
-
Last edited Sep 14, 2014
075073078071
Joined
May 2014
Messages
211
Likes
0
Sep 13, 2014 at 7:44 PM#2
A brawl at LS-RP, and it looks so fun.

[video=youtube;FMluItiO6b0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMluItiO6b0[/video]
075073078071
Joined
May 2014
Messages
211
Likes
0
Sep 13, 2014 at 7:50 PM#3
If you don't want to brawl, you could just easily decline, and begin to fight with /me's.
Member
Joined
Jul 2014
Messages
79
Likes
0
Sep 13, 2014 at 8:55 PM#4
Stuff like this is indeed actually interesting, fighting with /me's sucks.

+1

EDIT : Just to this, it rocks!!! Especially since nobody can PG, Like "I weigh 120 kg and I am 2 meters tall, I am very muscular", some people have this, and it's just so cheap, it gives other people no chance to even wanna start a fight, but this eliminates it! :)
Last edited Sep 13, 2014
S
Donator
Joined
Sep 2013
Messages
84
Likes
0
Sep 15, 2014 at 10:47 PM#5
-1 I could see some excessive trolling with this, as I already have seen.
Brandon McKinneyCommissioner of State Police DepartmentAlive
Brandon ReidReid FamigliaAlive
Henry ReidEx-Reid FamigliaDead
Rick SantorelliSan Andreas Oil CorporationAlive
Brandy WilliamsHookerAlive
MTA:RP Forum Legend
Joined
Oct 2012
Messages
2,038
Likes
3
Sep 16, 2014 at 7:45 AM#6
+1
Spoiler
The Dinapoli Family
2012-2015


Your weekly report count is: 336

Spoiler

Thanks to DrJoseEvil for this lovely painting.

Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
lol
Spoiler
T
Member
Joined
Apr 2013
Messages
25
Likes
1
Sep 16, 2014 at 8:49 AM#7
-1
MTA:RP
If anything, I could see this promoting more PG. As no injuries would be RPed. Oh, you've been hit in the face 5 times, let me just keep hitting you back. It seems that it would promote more of an RPG style server, and could ultimately lead to RDM.
Thanks to Bestorio for the Signature
075073078071
Joined
May 2014
Messages
211
Likes
0
Sep 17, 2014 at 7:42 PM#8
-1
MTA:RP
If anything, I could see this promoting more PG. As no injuries would be RPed. Oh, you've been hit in the face 5 times, let me just keep hitting you back. It seems that it would promote more of an RPG style server, and could ultimately lead to RDM.

You're wrong bottom line, I've seen this in other roleplay servers, and actually participated in this style of fighting it does not promote more power gaming, but actually decreases it. People can, and do take more than 5 punches to the face in real life, and do continue to hit back. This will not promote more of RPG style server as long as administration monitors it correctly. There will be no more of "Don diesel has big arm, he is king". No more crying, bitching, moaning. You fight until either one starts to bleed, fight until one gives up, or fight until PK. BUT you MUST have OOC agreements from both sides to brawl that's the key to making this successful. You will still need a IC reason to fight, and still will roleplay injuries after the fight.
Server Supervisor
Joined
Aug 2013
Messages
1,502
Likes
17
🎮 3,255 hrs💰 $1.6M
Sep 17, 2014 at 8:34 PM#9
Seems like it would be used as an excuse for Death Matching..
Member
Joined
Dec 2013
Messages
67
Likes
0
🎮 300 hrs💰 $302K
Sep 17, 2014 at 8:37 PM#10
I can see it avoiding stupid QQing and playing to win but I'm already seeing this getting shot down. I've also played on those servers that do this.
Former MTA-RP Super Admin
Former SPD Deputy Commissioner

Character NameEmploymentStatus
Eliah EisenstadtNothingAlive
Joseph CrossfordUnemployedAlive

Thank you CutiePie and Deli for signature pic.
075073078071
Joined
May 2014
Messages
211
Likes
0
Sep 17, 2014 at 8:40 PM#11
Seems like it would be used as an excuse for Death Matching..

Both sides must have come to an OOC agreement, and there must be an IC reason to start an brawl (just like there must be an IC reason to start any fight in-game). If there's any suspicion that there's death matching, have one, or both pull up logs to show proof of the IC reason.

As I said, again OOC agreement from both side, and an IC reason. It's not like people are going to run up from no where, and begin to punch each other for no reason.
075073078071
Joined
May 2014
Messages
211
Likes
0
Sep 17, 2014 at 8:41 PM#12
I can see it avoiding stupid QQing and playing to win but I'm already seeing this getting shot down. I've also played on those servers that do this.

Our competition does it, and it works perfectly. I have never had any issues with this type of system. It actually feels like a huge burden has been lifted off your shoulders while using it. It's completely fair for both sides.
Member
Joined
Dec 2013
Messages
67
Likes
0
🎮 300 hrs💰 $302K
Sep 17, 2014 at 8:44 PM#13
Our competition does it, and it works perfectly. I have never had any issues with this type of system. It actually feels like a huge burden has been lifted off your shoulders while using it. It's completely fair for both sides.

Oh I completely agree, I've played on numerous SA-MP servers that do this and it makes fighting actually fun and interesting, instead of the QQ OOC bullshit festival it usually is. I'm just saying I can see the administration coming by and shooting this down. But I'll +1 it anyways.
Former MTA-RP Super Admin
Former SPD Deputy Commissioner

Character NameEmploymentStatus
Eliah EisenstadtNothingAlive
Joseph CrossfordUnemployedAlive

Thank you CutiePie and Deli for signature pic.
075073078071
Joined
May 2014
Messages
211
Likes
0
Sep 17, 2014 at 8:50 PM#14
At the end of the day, we're all here to have fun without having headaches when it comes to playing the game. If there's no fun, and the game is nothing but headaches, what's the point in playing? That's the way I look at it, and many other people most likely do as well. I hope the administration will at least give it some thought, and look at it in a players point of view, and also an administrators point of view. This also benefit administrators as well, there will be a lot less PG reports that take up their valuable time that could be put to use elsewhere.
Donator
Joined
Feb 2014
Messages
664
Likes
2
🎮 2,921 hrs💰 $7.1M
Sep 18, 2014 at 7:15 AM#15
+1
P.S I like how you keep posting ideas like that vanilla, keep it up :D
MTA:RP Forum Legend
Joined
Dec 2012
Messages
1,979
Likes
4
Sep 19, 2014 at 11:00 AM#16
I see no problem. Implemented.
“I know, up on top you are seeing great sights, but down here at the bottom we, too, should have rights.”
― Dr. Seuss, Yertle the Turtle and Gertrude McFuzz

Contact me: here.
Serb
Joined
Mar 2014
Messages
660
Likes
0
Sep 19, 2014 at 2:24 PM#17
Just going to say one thing, Make it so when a person gets the "Low health" Icon above them they stop and the person with that icon has to RP their injuries. You could say in this situation once "low health" comes up that could mean you are knocked out, Letting the other person/people rob, kidnap, kill(etc) you
Red Dragons 4 Life


Spoiler
Here Lies something that roasted a certain someone.


Setting DrJoseEvil to sleep
Before: http://i.imgur.com/ZRXVboB.png
After: http://i.imgur.com/1Elepdn.png
K
Donator
Joined
Jul 2013
Messages
23
Likes
0
Nov 16, 2014 at 7:22 PM#18
Just going to say one thing, Make it so when a person gets the "Low health" Icon above them they stop and the person with that icon has to RP their injuries. You could say in this situation once "low health" comes up that could mean you are knocked out, Letting the other person/people rob, kidnap, kill(etc) you

Ive done this before and it was always done this way. Low health = knocked out
P
New member
Joined
Jul 2014
Messages
2
Likes
0
Nov 18, 2014 at 5:18 AM#19
Yes, Yes this idea is kinda similar to driving as you wouldn't RP "/me turns steering wheel left and right etc etc..".
Although rp'ing crashes, taking off, engine roaring, tyre screeches, Similar to the after effect of what happened in a brawl. Time consuming trying to RP a brawl while not much action happens plain and boring.

Like Ray Payne stated above:
Just going to say one thing, Make it so when a person gets the "Low health" Icon above them they stop and the person with that icon has to RP their injuries. You could say in this situation once "low health" comes up that could mean you are knocked out, Letting the other person/people rob, kidnap, kill(etc) you

Low health shows taken severe damage, Although melee weapons should be 2 hits then getting to "Low health"
Also hitting them should pop up a location where they've been hit, ETC: "CJ has been hit at their torso", Popping up automatically.
Therefore it'll be more realistic making players to RP damage, Rather than getting hit by melee weapons over 10 times before they get "Low Health".

Big +1
Last edited Nov 18, 2014
Member
Joined
Jul 2014
Messages
79
Likes
0
Nov 18, 2014 at 6:41 AM#20
I see no problem. Implemented.

I hope it is "truely" implemented by now.
You must log in or register to reply here.